5 Mistakes People Make When Filing with Sedgwick (And How to Avoid Them)

Published 9:04 pm Tuesday, June 17, 2025

Dealing with insurance claims is honestly nobody’s idea of a good time. Filing Sedgwick claims can be especially frustrating if you’re trying to figure it out for the first time while you’re already stressed about whatever happened to you.

Here’s the thing though. While the process might look pretty straightforward on paper, there are all these little ways to mess it up that can derail your claim. Small mistakes turn into big delays, denials, or this endless back-and-forth with representatives who seem to speak a completely different language.

The good news is that most of these problems are totally avoidable once you know what to watch out for. Knowing the common pitfalls upfront can save you so much stress and actually help you get the outcome you deserve instead of getting stuck in bureaucratic hell.

Subscribe to our free email newsletter

Get the latest news sent to your inbox

Sedgwick has seen every mistake in the book, and they’re not going to cut you any slack just because you didn’t know better. But if you go in prepared and avoid these major slip-ups, your chances of getting approved go way up.

Missing Documentation or Incomplete Forms

This is honestly the biggest claim killer, and it’s so frustrating because it’s totally preventable. Sedgwick is absolutely ruthless about paperwork. Missing even one form or failing to provide the right medical records can completely stall your claim for weeks or months.

You really need to double-check every single deadline, make sure you’ve got all the required signatures, and fill out every single box on every form. Even if something seems optional or not relevant to your situation, fill it out anyway. Leaving blanks gives them an excuse to send everything back.

Are you keeping copies of everything you submit? You absolutely should be. Keep personal copies of every form, every medical record, every piece of documentation you send them. When they inevitably claim they never received something, you’ll have proof that you sent it.

The worst part is that incomplete submissions don’t just delay your claim. They often reset the whole timeline, so you’re basically starting over from scratch. That’s weeks or months of waiting that you could have avoided by being thorough the first time.

Relying Too Heavily on Your Employer

This is where a lot of people get completely blindsided. Many folks assume their HR department is handling the claim or at least helping them through the process, but Sedgwick operates totally independently from your employer.

Your employer might have filed the initial incident report, but after that, you’re pretty much on your own. They’re not going to follow up for you, and they definitely aren’t going to advocate on your behalf if something goes wrong.

It’s honestly your responsibility to stay on top of every update, every submission, every deadline. Sedgwick doesn’t care if your HR person said they’d handle something or if you thought your supervisor was supposed to submit paperwork. If it doesn’t get done, your claim suffers.

Some employers are helpful and will check in with you, but don’t count on it. Treat this like it’s entirely your responsibility from day one, and you won’t get caught off guard when nobody else steps up to help.

Not Following Up Regularly

One of the absolute biggest complaints about Sedgwick is the complete lack of communication. They’ll receive your paperwork and then you hear absolutely nothing for weeks. But here’s the thing, silence doesn’t mean everything’s fine. It usually means something’s sitting in a pile somewhere.

You need to call or message them consistently to confirm they actually received your documents and to check on your claim status. Don’t wait for them to contact you because they probably won’t until they need something else or they’re ready to deny your claim.

Get names, dates, and reference numbers for every single interaction you have with them. Write it all down because you’ll need it later when someone else tells you they have no record of what the previous person promised you.

The squeaky wheel really does get the grease with insurance companies. If you’re not actively staying on top of your claim, it’s going to sit at the bottom of someone’s pile while other people who are being more persistent get their claims processed first.

Ignoring Medical Advice or Missing Appointments

This is honestly one of the easiest ways to torpedo your own claim without even realizing it. If you skip treatment appointments or don’t follow your doctor’s recommended care plan, Sedgwick will absolutely use that to question whether your claim is legitimate.

They’re looking for any reason to suggest that you’re not really injured or that you’re not taking your recovery seriously. Missing appointments or ignoring medical advice gives them exactly the ammunition they need to deny your claim.

Always document every single medical visit and follow your prescribed care plans as closely as possible. If something needs to change about your treatment, make sure your doctor documents why and let Sedgwick know right away with updated medical records.

Even if you’re feeling better or you think a particular treatment isn’t helping, don’t just stop showing up. Talk to your doctor about modifying your treatment plan and make sure everything is properly documented before you make any changes.

Conclusion

Getting a Sedgwick claim approved honestly takes way more than just filling out some forms and hoping for the best. It requires persistence, serious attention to detail, and a really proactive approach to managing every aspect of your claim.

Avoiding these common mistakes puts you in a much better position to actually get the support you’re entitled to without dealing with unnecessary delays or denials. The system isn’t designed to be easy, but if you know what you’re doing and stay on top of everything, you can make it work for you instead of against you.